I’ve been on holiday the past couple of weeks and I didn’t want to watch The Mandalorian on my phone, so I fell behind quite a bit on the show. I’ve arrived back in Australia now, and had a marathon viewing of episodes five through seven (I watched four the week before I left but wasn’t able to type up a review). Below are my spoiler thoughts, episode-by-episode. None of these is as thorough as a full review, just a stream-of-consciousness rundown of my opinions on each episode.
s1e4: ‘Sanctuary’

This episode felt like filler. Enjoyable filler, but filler nonetheless. I guess I should have expected a Star Wars show to get around to doing a Seven Samurai episode at one point (The Clone Wars did one too), but that doesn’t make watching a story structure everyone’s seen a million times any less lame. The episode was also very dark, and I don’t mean tonally. I couldn’t see a damn thing in some scenes. Hilariously, the episode was directed by Bryce Dallas Howard, actress and daughter of Ron, who directed Solo: A Star Wars Story, another thing that is hugely underlit. I guess she was copying her dad’s directing style…? Anyway, I don’t want to completely trash the episode – there were some cool things. One of these things was Cara Dune, an ex-Rebel shocktrooper who is introduced in this episode. I’ll admit that I didn’t immediately like her, but I definitely warmed up to her over the episode and episode seven, when she comes back. She’s a cool character and it’s great that she’s back later in the season. Another thing I liked was the melancholy Mando has in the episode, being completely isolated from the rest of the galaxy and forced to live a life of few attachments. It adds a lot of credence to his relationship with Baby Yoda. If the Prequels had had this sort of emotion with Anakin, his fall to the Dark Side would have been much more believable. A mixed bag of an episode overall.
Score: 5/10
s1e5: ‘The Gunslinger’

I’d heard going in that this was the most divisive episode of the show thus far, so I was expecting something like The Last Jedi, but no? It was just a normal episode with none of the crazy stuff I was expecting. It takes place on Tatooine, which I definitely wasn’t expecting, but the script (by Dave Filoni) barely touches the lore surrounding the planet. Mando visits the Mos Eisley cantina and that’s about it. There are some fan service-y moments that are maybe a little much (I liked how they recreated the opening shot of the original film but things like ‘she’s no use to us dead’ was a bit far in terms of winking to the Star Wars-loving audience). It’s an alright episode. Although episode four felt unnecessary while watching it, the show later justifies it’s existence – this episode felt completely pointless to the overall plot. Unless some of the aspects of this episode come back in the finale, I can only assume that this episode was only here to visit Tatooine. There are some cool bits such as the climax when Mando kills his bounty hunter friend (can’t remember his name, sorry) and the character of Fennec Shand, a very intriguing assassin I wish we could have seen more of. One of the more forgettable episodes of the season.
Score: 5/10
s1e6: ‘The Prisoner’

After a couple of lacklustre episodes, ‘The Prisoner’ went a long way in restoring my faith in The Mandalorian. It’s a fun prison break episode with some interesting new characters and great action. Mando is developed further as he argues against killing the New Republic guard. It also added to the lore of the period post-Jedi, pre-Awakens by showing us a New Republic prison and it’s inhabitants and introducing us to some cool new droids. This is probably the most canon-heavy episode so far, dropping references to Gungans and Canto Bight. To top it all off, Mando directors Filoni, Rick Fumuyiwa and Deborah Chow appear as X-Wing pilots! They’re not actors so the scene was a little stiff but it was still really fun to see them on screen. I’m not going to make out like this was a masterpiece of television storytelling; it isn’t. It’s just a fun forty minutes in the Star Wars universe and that”s really all I wanted from this episode.
Score: 7/10
s1e7: ‘the reckoning’

Deborah Chow is the directorial MVP of this season, and she returned to direct this episode with great results. This is the penultimate installment, which surprised me because I thought the season was meant to be ten episodes long, not eight. Quick side note: the episode also has a short sneak peek at The Rise of Skywalker at the end. I’m not going to speculate on the clip because at the time of writing I’ve already seen Episode IX. I know I said I was prioritising the film over The Mandalorian but I realised that I have a lot to say about the former and I’ll never get this post done in time if I review the movie first, hence why it’s coming out first. Anyway, this was a really good episode. It was really fun to see the team coming together and their chemistry with each other. Carl Weathers gets a lot of good moments and I enjoyed the fake-out – where you think Werner Herzog is going to be the main villain but then he gets killed immediately – with an asterisk. The asterisk is that it’s a little concerning that Jon Favreau now has to set up the more-or-less main villain for the season, Moff Gideon, in a single episode. But all the episodes thus far have been more or less self-contained short films set in the Star Wars galaxy so the show might be able to pull it off. On a different note, I’m sad that they killed Kuiil! The way that it was revealed (by showing his corpse rather than actually showing him getting killed) was very effective for tension. To end the review on a very minor thing – it was so cool to see Death Troopers again. I love Death Troopers.
Score: 8/10
Well, there you go. We’re up to date on The Mandalorian. My next priority is The Rise of Skywalker (woo boy I have some thoughts), followed by next week’s Mandalorian finale, so look forward to those two!










Holiday Special Nods: THEY MENTIONED LIFE DAY!!!!!!


